PDF Print E-mail

Glycemic Index and fat differentiation shed new light on high fat and low carbs debate.

Legend has it that 200 years ago a large community lived in and around the Mediterranean Sea.  This community was very healthy and happy, but ambition obliged them to cross the Atlantic Ocean in an attempt to strive for a more prosperous way of life.  Their ambitions and wishes were realised and after a hundred years they became the richest country in the world, but unfortunately their health deteriorated.  Their Mediterranean diet changed to a staple diet of hamburgers, ribs, chips and cream in their coffee.  Many people became fat and/or sick, some dying from their new diet.  Heart diseases, cancer and conditions such as diabetes and obesity hit their community hard.

They became aware that saturated fats were responsible for this deterioration and changed their staple diet to include muffins and bagels (refined carbohydrates).  A large selection of sweetened cool drinks was developed to enable the population to slake their thirst.  Meanwhile portion sizes also increased dramatically and even more people quickly became fatter and less healthy.  Some doctors started to wonder if the hamburger and chips diet was not perhaps better than the bagel and Coke diet.

However, there is still a large number of people living in good health around the Mediterranean Sea.  Unlike the pioneers who enjoy hamburgers, ribs, chips,  muffins and Coke those who remained behind maintained a diet that had hardly changed in 2 centuries.  They stayed with their traditional diet that consisted of whole grains, no red meat or eggs or chicken, low quantities of low fat dairy and lots of fish, as well as healthy quantities of olive oil, olives and nuts and lots of vegetables, salads and fruit. They still enjoy the same food they always had and still enjoy very good health. But some doctors still wonder if the hamburger and chips diet is not perhaps better than the bagel and Coke diet….

END OF LEGEND

The whole high fat and low carbohydrates debate raises its head every few decades.  But it is now the 21st century and since the introduction of the glycaemic index (GI) in 1981 (Jenkins et al, 1981) GI has finally become part of the debate. It brings a whole new perspective to the table.  Detailed studies have shown that a diet high in high GI (refined) carbohydrates indeed promotes many illnesses including heart diseases (Jacobsen et al, 2010 and Liu and Willett, 2000), diabetes (Salmeron et al, 1997a and b), cancer (Augustin et al, 2001) as well as overweight and obesity (Pawlak et al, 2004).

It is for this very reason that lower GI-carbohydrates should be preferred in a daily diet, many of them being staple foods in the Mediterranean diet, namely oats, whole grain bread, brown rice and legumes (Bond Brill, 2009).  Low GI-carbohydrates are well known to not raise blood glucose levels too much, to lead to less insulin being produced by the pancreas, lessens pancreatic activity and in so doing helps to prevent diabetes and other life style diseases (Craoi et akm 1977, Pawlak et al, 2004, Jacobsen et al, 2010, Liu en Willett, 2000, Salmeron et al, 1977a and b and Augustin et al, 2001). Low GI foods offer protection from heart diseases (Jacobsen et al, 2010), lead to improvement in diseases such as diabetes (Brand Miller et al, 2003 and Opperman et al, 2004) and better weight loss than any other diet (McMillan-Price et al, 2006).

The Mediterranean diet is not shy of fat, but it consists substantially of mono and poly-unsaturated fats (mainly obtained from omega-3 poly-unsaturated fatty acids).  It has been conclusively proved that when saturated fats in the diet are replaced with mono and poly-unsaturated fats (omega-3 and 6) insulin sensitivity is increased which helps prevent diabetes (Riserus et al, 2009), reduces dangerous LdL-cholesterol whilst increasing advantageous HdL-cholesterol and prevents heart diseases (Kaushik et al, 2009) and drastically reduces the risk of various cancers such as colon cancer (World Cancer Research Fund, 2007).

It has been shown in many studies that a diet high in saturated fat has been coupled with high levels of LdL-cholesterol, weakened functioning of cell membranes (Haag and Dippenaar , 2005) and increased risk of heart disease and other life style diseases, including overweight (Ascherio, 2002, Hu et al, 2001 and Hu and Wukkett, 2002), as well as increased risk of cancer e.g. breast cancer (Kushi and Giovannucci, 2002).  No studies show any advantage to the use of saturated fats and in no country’s heart foundation do they recommend the increased intake thereof.  Prof Nola Dippenaar suggests that not more than 30% of your total fat intake of 10% of your kilojule intake should be saturated fat. The rest should consist of mono-unsaturated fats (half) and poly-unsaturated fats (half). In the South African context we should aim to include omega 3 daily, because it is not generally available in our diet and has many advantages, such as protection against Alzheimer’s disease and improvements in concentration and insulin sensitivity (Haag and Dippenaar , 2005), decrease of triglycerides and blood pressure etc.

Healthy diet is a matter of balance and there is general agreement between dieticians and nutritionists that a healthy diet should consist of 50% carbohydrate, 30% fat and 15 – 20% protein.  The energy intake must be balanced by the energy usage otherwise one is liable to become fat regardless of whether the diet is higher in fat or carbohydrates. Most of us also tends take in far too much macro-nutrients and too few micro-nutrients that are obtained from vegetables and fruit.

In my 30 years experience as dietician, I have noticed that it is almost impossible for most people to follow a diet that contains less than 50% carbohydrates. When skimping on the better foods like slower absorbed carbohydrates, fruits, vegetables, nuts and other good fat and lower fat protein sources they break out only to crave sweets, high fat foods, alcoholic drinks or meat, all the bad stuff.  They end up have too little energy to exercise and don’t lose any weight and definitely not fat mass.  Read Roald’s case study. Research by Harvard underscores this, that people who consistently choose the less nutritious foods on a consistent basis do indeed pick up weight and increase their risk to the major lifestyle diseases. Read more.   As soon as they begin eating GI smart, (i.e. low GI when inactive and before exercise, but higher GI during extended periods of exercise), as well as eating fat smart (i.e. lower fat with a focus on healthy fats), their cravings disappear and they have enough energy to exercise and they lose weight and mostly body fat.  This type of diet is much easier to become a life style.  Read the case study of Jacques

As the Glycaemic Index of SA (GIFSA) we have tried to capture this healthy, balanced diet pattern with the words “GI Smart – Fat Smart” eating.  With food science development to date it will be irresponsible to ignore the types of carbohydrates (GI) and types of fats.


Elizabeth Delport RD (SA), M.Sc Dietetics
Research Manager: GI Foundation of SA,
www.gifoundation.com,


References:

Ascherio A. Epidemiologic Studies on Dietary fat & CHD (2002): Am J Med, 113 (supp 9B): 9S - 12S.

Augustin LS, Dal Maso L, La Vecchia C, Parpinel M, Negri E, Vaccarella S, et al (2001): Dietary glycemic index and glycemic load and bread cancer risk: as case-control study. Ann. of Onc. 12, 1533–1538.

Brand Miller J, Hayne S, Petocz P and Colagiuri S (2003): Low Glycemic Index diets in the management of diabetes. Diab Care 26(8): 2261 – 2267.

Bond Brill Janet (2009): The Mediterranean diet and your health. Am J Lifestyle Med, Jan/Feb: 44 – 56.

Crapo PA, Reaven MD, Olefsky J. (1977): Postprandial plasma-glucose and –insulin responses to different complex carbohydrates. Diab, 26(12):1178– 83.


Haag M en Dippenaar NG (2005): Dietary fats, fatty acids and insulin resistance: short review of a multifaceted connection. Med Sci Monit, 11(12): RA359 – 367. http://www.gifoundation.com/attachments/article/83/DietaryFats,FattyAcidsandIR-Haag,Dippenaar.pdf

Hu F & Manson J and Willett W (2001): Types of dietary fat and risk of coronary heart disease: a critical review. J Am Coll Nutr, 20: 5 – 19.

Hu FB and Wukkett WC (2002): Optimal diets for prevention of coronary heart disease. JAMA, 288: 256.

Jacobsen MU and Dethlefsen C, et al. (2010): Intake of carbohydrates compared with intake of saturated fatty acids and risk of myocardial infarction: importance of the glycemic index. Am J Clin Nutr,  91:1764 – 8.

Jenkins DJA, Wolever TMS, Taylor RH, Barker H, Fielden H, Baldwin JM, et al. (1981): Glycemic index of foods: a physiological basis for carbohydrate exchange. Am J Clin Nutr, 34:362–6.

Kaushik M, Mozaffarian D and Spiegelmann et al (2009): Long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, fish intake and the risk of type 2 diabetes mellitus. Am J Clin Nutr, 90:613 – 20.

Kushi L and Giovannucci E (2002): Dietary fat and cancer. Am J Med, 113 Suppl 9B: 63S – 70S.

Liu S, Willett WC, Stampfer MJ, Hu FB, Franz M, et al (2000): A prospective study of dietary glycemic load, carbohydrate intake and risk of coronary heart diease in US women. Am J Clin Nutr,  71(6), 1455-1461.

McMillan-Price and J Petoca P, et al (2006): Comparison of 4 Diets of varying Glycemic Load on weight loss and cardiovascular risk reduction in overweight & obese young adults. Arch Intern Med, 166:1466 – 1475.

Opperman  AM, Venter CS, Oosthuizen W, Thompson RL and Vorster HH (2004): Meta-analysis of the health effects of using the Glycemic Index in meal planning. B Jnl Nutr, 367 – 381.

Pawlak DB, Kushner JA and Ludwig DS (2004): Effects of dietary glycaemic index on adiposity, glucose homeostasis and plasma lipids in animals. Lancet, 364:778–85.

Salmeron J, Ascherio A, Rimm EB, Colditz GA, Spiegelman D, Jenkins DJ, et al (1997a): Dietary fibre, glycemic load and risk of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in men. Diab Care, 20(4), 545–550. & Salmeron J, Manson JE, Stampfer MJ, Colditz GA, Wing AL & Willett WC (1997b): Dietary fibre, glycemic load and risk of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in women.  J Am Med Ass, 277(6), 472-477.

World Cancer Research Fund, American Institute for Candcer Research (2007): Food, nutrition, physical activity and the prevention of caner: a Global Perspective. Online, Accessed January 11, 2012.